Skip to main content
Unraveling the Myth of Plant Pain: The Science Behind Bonsai and Nature's Resilience

Unraveling the Myth of Plant Pain: The Science Behind Bonsai and Nature's Resilience

·681 words·4 mins· 0 · 0 ·
Pritam Sharma
Author
Pritam Sharma

Bonsai, often seen as an art form that involves meticulously pruning and shaping plants, has garnered mixed opinions. Some argue that it is a form of plant torture, akin to foot binding in humans. However, the idea of plants experiencing pain is a topic of confusion and misconception. In this article, we will delve into the science behind plant perception, pain receptors, and the adaptations that make plants resilient beings. By the end, readers will gain a clearer understanding of why plants do not feel pain and can decide for themselves whether practicing Bonsai is a controversial practice.

Cut and shaped plants
Plants have evolved to serve two purposes: as an alarm system to detect threats and as an educational tool to enhance survival. While they can react to damage, it is important to distinguish between pain and healing. Pain is a response that indicates potential damage, while healing involves exploration of various factors like texture, shape, and temperature. Pain receptors and sensory receptors are separate pathways in organisms, and it is possible for organisms to have sensory perception without feeling pain.
Mass cutting of trees
To experience pain, organisms need to fulfill two criteria: having pain receptors and possessing a complex enough nervous system to interpret pain. Based on these criteria, it is evident that birds, reptiles, amphibians, and even fish can feel pain. However, plants lack pain receptors and a complex nervous system. They have evolved to respond to tissue damage from predation, attracting insects that combat threats, but they cannot prevent damage nor move away from it.
Trees enduring pain by wild fire
Plants’ inability to move or escape their environment is a significant factor in understanding why they do not need to evolve pain. It would not be advantageous for plants to experience pain in situations where they are at the mercy of their surroundings, such as being consumed by herbivores, damaged by falling trees, or subjected to forest fires.

The belief that plants feel pain might stem from humans projecting their own experiences onto nature. Humans, being a caring species, tend to anthropomorphize the sensations of other organisms. However, understanding the experiences of other organisms is challenging, as we can only comprehend what it’s like to be human. Scientific terms should be used accurately and avoid misinterpretation, especially when discussing sensitive topics like pain.

One popular article often cited as evidence of plant torture is titled “Plants Emit Ultrasonic Squeals When Stressed.” However, this article merely highlights research that certain plants produce ultrasonic vibrations when cut or dehydrated. It does not suggest that plants feel pain or scream. The misrepresentation of scientific information in sensationalized journalism further confuses the general public.

In conclusion, the question of whether plants feel pain is complex and subject to scientific updates. While it is always possible that new discoveries may emerge, current evidence suggests that plants do not experience pain in the same way as animals. Instead of focusing on whether Bonsai is cruel or not, it is crucial to acknowledge the remarkable adaptations plants possess. They have mastered the art of adaptation, enduring everything from natural disasters to the test of time.

The disconnection between humans and nature is a more pressing concern. Our relationship with the natural world has become strained, and we often view nature solely through the lens of its benefits to us. However, appreciating and respecting plants should be an individual choice, with an understanding that they are deeply cared for and have the potential to live for hundreds of years. Ultimately, the decision to practice Bonsai or not rests with the individual, bearing in mind that plants do not experience pain in the same way animals do.

Summary: #

This article explores the concept of plant pain and its relevance to practices like Bonsai. It clarifies that plants do not possess pain receptors or a complex nervous system, making pain an unlikely experience for them. The article emphasizes the remarkable adaptations of plants and the need to reconnect with nature, appreciating its intrinsic value. While the debate may continue, understanding the scientific evidence and considering the welfare of plants is vital in making informed decisions regarding their treatment.